There has been lots of chatter of what the agency of the future may be. Today within the overall marketing industry business models are influx, capabilities are disparate and the selection process is rocky at best.
Looking at the marketing landscape, there are many firms clamouring to help companies create preference. Generally speaking there are three types of areas where companies can influence in order to help customers decide. They are brand purpose, brand experiences and brand messaging.
It’s important to note that offers between agency lines are blurring with each area building off of the other. In these times of shifting technologies and consumer preference, it would seem that clients need one lead agency across these three fields to create a consistent brand experience.
In a nutshell here is how each of these sectors break out…
Brand Purpose
Primarily functions as an internal tool to help employees understand why a business exists and what role each employee plays within an organization. In this instance brand is used to help a company define what its offer is to the world as a point of distinction.
This space has traditionally been where brand consultancies and design shops have lived to help define or clarify a business offer. But today these firms are looking to work more downstream to help define and create branded experiences. Firms like Anomaly, WhatIF and Landor are all moving in this direction.
Brand Experiences
Are the things a brand creates to deliver on a brand promise. The better experiences brands create the greater chance they have of influencing preference. Digital shops and production studios have traditionally lived in this space by translating brand values into physical or virtual destinations that consumers can interact with.
Out of this need production studios have emerged and are looking to become more strategic. On the digital side companies like R/GA, The Barbarian Group and HUGE are looking to get smarter about the experiences they create. On the studio side companies like Fitch have developed expertise in packaging, and site build outs. In common digital shops and production studios are looking to work more upstream to help craft the brand purpose by using customer insights to define what the experience should be.
Brand Messaging
Are the actions that a brand wants it customers to take. Messaging serves to guide actions and create a dialogue to build on the experiences and purpose of a brand. Traditionally PR firms and advertising agencies have crafted the messaging to drive loyalty or build awareness.
This has often taken shape in a campaign that is defined by where a customer lives. The preferred medium has traditionally been TV but has quickly moved online. These agencies are looking to work upstream to help companies define consumer culture to help influence how brands should speak to the world. This is where the Crispin Porter’s and Widen + Kennedy’s of the world have sought to define themselves.
In each instance all companies are looking to use brand as means to create preference. Consulting firms are using brand to define a business purpose. Digital shops are using brand to translate business objectives into branded experience and advertising agencies are using brand messaging to influence the actions they want customers to take.
The question is who provides the most value for a business?
From an organizational standpoint I would argue that the brand consultancy does. From the outset they help to define the offer and how an organization should deliver on their brand promise.
The challenge that the latter two groups face is one of re-education. All agencies need to be briefed and indoctrinated into an organization’s culture if they are to successfully create experiences and messages that are on brand. This creates breaks in the process that cost money and valuable time.
Consultancies have the advantage of setting parameters for business growth. But unfortunately consultancies are not yet full scale shops. They can not yet develop branded experiences. More often than not, they lack the in-house facilities and expertise to build, prototype and deliver physical assets. While on the other hand, production studios lack strategic focus which often results in disparate consumer experiences.
Then there are the advertising agencies and PR firms. Often the messages they create either over deliver on the brand promise or do not enhance the brand at all. Target’s advertising does this. Their agencies develop beautiful imagery and tell great brand stories, but the reality of the in-store experience always falls short of the messaging. On the other side of the spectrum brands like Cadillac has amazing brand stories. Cadillac’s brand is positioned to blend art and science to create iconic vehicles, yet this story doesn’t come across in their advertising, leaving customers to draw their own conclusions about what they think the brand is.
These missteps are often a direct result of the agency hand-off process, which can be cumbersome at best. As it stands today, no one agency is adequately equipped to lead as a full service partner, but a few key strategic agencies can help to coordinate the process like a brand consulting firm.
The agency of the future many not be one lead agency but a handful of strategically led businesses that act and coordinate as one brand ambassador for a client.
(George)